Ray Peat Right Again (RPRA): High-phosphate diet (meat/grains/legumes) causes mitochondria damage that “even” exercise fails to reverse

This is perhaps the first “modern” study over the last decade or so, which supports Ray’s highly “controversial” (read: true, but politically inconvenient) claim that high levels (relative to calcium) of phosphate intake through the diet results in mitochondrial impairments that persist after the high-phosphate exposure has been stopped and “even” after an exercise regimen has been implemented in an attempt to correct the mitochondrial issues. I put the “even” in the title in quotes, because I am not sold that exhaustive exercise has universally beneficial effects, especially in cases of mitochondrial malfunction, and the study confirms that position of mine (and Ray’s). Namely, the study shows that while exercise did increase mitochondrial biogenesis, it failed to fully resolve the mitochondrial dysfunction caused by the high-phosphate diet. Interestingly, the high-phosphate diet did not result in reduced exercise performance, which suggests that endurance alone cannot be used s a gauge or health. In other words, just because a bad diet has not reduced a person’s exercise capacity (yet), it does not mean the diet is not silently creating a pathology that would manifest at a later date, including eventually in poor exercise performance. Since mitochondrial respiration was lower in the high-phosphate diet, but exercise performance was the same, it suggests that the energetic deficit created by the high-phosphate diet was somehow compensated for by the organism – likely, through increased ATP generation from glycolysis, which means higher lactate production and increased reductive stress. So, IMO this study casts doubt on the recommendation by virtually all doctors to engage in (endurance) exercise as a way to restore (metabolic) health and reduce risk of conditions such as diabetes, CVD, neurological disease, cancer, etc which have, by now, all been linked to persistent mitochondrial dysfunction. It remains to be tested by future studies whether increasing calcium intake, which was one of Ray’s recommendation, would correct the mitochondrial pathology induced by high phosphate intake. However, I think the study below makes it clear that for now it is best not to overload on phosphates. That means avoiding consuming large amounts of meat, grains or legumes, all of which have high levels of phosphate relative to calcium, or at least supplement generously with calcium if the high-phosphate diet is unavoidable.

https://doi.org/10.14814/phy2.71139

Exercise fails to restore mitochondrial function in high-phosphate-fed male mice

“…In a controlled mouse experiment, nine weeks of voluntary wheel running improved treadmill endurance and produced broad changes in skeletal-muscle gene expression, but it did not restore mitochondrial respiratory capacity in gastrocnemius plantaris muscle. Adult male C57BL/6 mice received either a normal-phosphate diet containing 0.6% inorganic phosphate or a high-phosphate diet containing 2.0% for 14 weeks. After five weeks, animals were assigned to sedentary conditions or given access to running wheels for the remaining nine weeks. Trained mice on the high-phosphate diet ran as long as their normal-phosphate-trained counterparts in a graded treadmill test, yet mitochondria isolated from their skeletal muscle continued to show reduced oxygen consumption. The study therefore separates an improvement in measured exercise performance from recovery of diet-associated cellular dysfunction.”

“…Mitochondrial impairment in skeletal muscle was detected after only five weeks of the high-phosphate diet. The researchers isolated mitochondria from gastrocnemius plantaris, a metabolically active muscle, and measured oxygen consumption with substrates linked to distinct respiratory pathways. With succinate under coupled conditions, high-phosphate-fed mice had significantly lower State 3 and maximal State 3U respiration than normal-phosphate-fed mice. In uncoupled assays using pyruvate and malate, respiration through electron-transport-chain complexes II through IV and through complex IV alone was also reduced. Mitochondria isolated from the liver did not differ significantly between diets at this stage. These measurements showed that mitochondrial respiratory changes were detectable in skeletal muscle at five weeks while they were not detectable in liver mitochondria under the same comparison.”

“…After fasting for two to five hours, the mice underwent a graded forced-treadmill test. Trained animals ran longer than sedentary mice in both dietary groups, and blood lactate increased after the test in every group. Trained high-phosphate-fed mice and trained normal-phosphate-fed mice showed similar exercise durations, as well as similar pre- and post-exercise lactate responses. This differed from an earlier mouse study in which 12 weeks of a high-phosphate diet reduced exercise capacity. In the current experiment, the measured endurance outcome was no longer reduced after training, even though the mitochondrial assays still identified respiratory impairment. The authors noted that lower respiration does not always indicate dysfunction because it can also reflect adaptation to altered physiological demands, but persistent metabolic gene dysregulation and prior evidence of impaired sedentary exercise capacity supported their interpretation that the sustained respiratory reduction was pathological.”

“…Direct assays of isolated mitochondria confirmed that the respiratory defect remained after training. High-phosphate-fed trained mice had significantly lower State 3 and State 3U respiration than normal-phosphate-fed trained mice when supplied with succinate under coupled conditions. Uncoupled respiration driven by pyruvate and malate was also reduced, including activity through complexes II–IV and complex IV alone. Fatty-acid oxidation was affected as well: when palmitoyl carnitine and malate were supplied, respiration through complexes II–IV was lower in high-phosphate-fed muscle mitochondria. Liver mitochondria showed no significant diet-related differences in coupled or uncoupled assays with succinate, pyruvate, or palmitoyl carnitine. Exploratory correlations found no relationship between daily running distance and skeletal-muscle respiration in the electron-coupling, electron-flow, or fatty-acid oxidation assays.”

“…The experiment distinguishes dietary phosphate loading, whole-animal exercise performance, and mitochondrial function. Nine weeks of voluntary running produced a clear training response, including altered body composition, longer treadmill duration, increased muscle mitochondrial DNA, and extensive gene-expression changes. It did not normalize phosphate exposure, skeletal-muscle respiration, or all diet-sensitive metabolic pathways. The study involved male mice, a controlled high-phosphate diet, and exercise initiated after five weeks, so it cannot establish how the same sequence would affect women, humans, people already active before increasing phosphate intake, or other exercise regimens. It also did not determine whether exercise started before the diet, combined with dietary phosphate reduction, or a different training program would prevent the defect. The narrow but clear result is that restored treadmill endurance and molecular signs of adaptation did not amount to restored mitochondrial respiratory capacity in this mouse model.”

Author: haidut